Charles Kurzman

Skip Navigation
  • 2013
  • 2014
  • 2015
  • 2016
  • 2017
  • 2018
  • 2019
  • A Century of Acceleration
  • Acknowledging State Terrorism
  • Americans’ unfavorable attitudes toward Muslims since 9/11, by party affiliation
  • Arab Spring
    • Winter Without Spring
  • Big Data and Mega Corpora in Middle East Studies
  • CHHS-2019-02-19
  • Confidentiality of Human Research Subjects, 1927
  • Covid Disparities in the United States
  • Crossword Cosmopolitanism
  • Death Tolls of the Iran-Iraq War
  • Forecasting
    • When Forecasts Fail
  • From Brain Drain to Brain Flush
  • International Education
    • Crippling International Education
    • How Global Is K-12 Education in America?
    • Sources and Data
  • Introducing Powerblindness
  • Making the United States Plural Again
  • Middle East Studies at Carolina
  • Nativism, Then and Now
  • Online Catalogs and the Invisible Heritage of Arab Libraries
  • Panopti-Claus
  • President Oligarch
  • Prosecuting Mass Destruction
  • Racial Inequality in the United States
  • Rightwing Postmodernists
  • Syria’s Four Revolutions
  • Syria’s Human Development Crisis
  • Teaching Middle East Crises
  • Ten Unfortunate Place-Names
  • Thank You, Civil Society
  • The Destruction of Syria
  • The Disparaging Implications of Strategic Location
  • The False Premise of Travel Ban 3.0
  • The Man Who Broke the World
  • The Meth Vote
  • When Republicans Needed Muslim Allies
  • Who Polices the Police?
  • Women’s Assessments of Gender Equality
  • #4 (no title)
  • Bio/Contact
  • Democracy Denied
  • Iran
    • Hard-Liners Agree: Good Riddance to Iran Nuclear Deal!
    • The Khomeini Wanna-Be
  • Curriculum Vitae
  • Islamic Parties
  • Islamic Terrorism
    • Chasing the Ghosts of Violent Extremism in the Middle East
    • Data Sources and Suggested Readings
    • Gremlins of Terror
    • Prism’s Paltry Yield
    • The Heresy of the Hijackers
    • The Rights of Roamers
  • Liberal Islam
    • Liberal Islam Web Links
  • Modernist Islam
  • Teaching/Advising
    • Teaching the Middle East in 10 Quiz Questions
    • Social Theory
  • Muslim-American Terrorism
    • Annual Report
    • Press Release, March 9, 2011
  • The Missing Martyrs
    • Q & A on The Missing Martyrs
  • World Peace
    • Will $500 Billion Make America Feel Secure?
Home » The Meth Vote

The Meth Vote

kurzman_clandestine_labs_2012-2015_by_countyCharles Kurzman, “The Meth Vote,” November 29, 2016.

This fall, the Department of Health and Human Services released its first detailed estimate of the number of methamphetamine users in the United States. The total: 897,000, located disproportionately in small cities and nonmetropolitan areas.

This is Trump country. Counties with the most clandestine drug lab busts — averaging one or more per year since 2012, according to addresses listed online (new address, 2018) by the Drug Enforcement Agency — supported Donald Trump over Hillary Clinton by a margin of more than 2 million votes, according to preliminary returns. Trump lost the popular vote in the rest of the country.

Even in rural areas, meth counties voted for Trump by a margin 9 percent greater than elsewhere.

Meth users and dealers are not numerous enough to make a difference on this scale, and they are not likely to be active voters in any case. In Catawba County, North Carolina, for example, 31 people were arrested for possession or sale of methamphetamines and other Schedule II substances in the month before this fall’s election. Of those, only 11 had ever voted.

But the meth industry is symptomatic of a broader public health crisis that spills over into drug crime, child welfare issues, Hepatitis C infection, and a variety of other problems. As Doug Urland, Catawba County’s health director, told me, “The root level is addiction, and we are still sorely lacking in access to mental health services.”

Across the country, small cities and rural areas are suffering an addiction epidemic. These areas have higher rates of abuse of pain relievers and prescription psychotherapeutics than in big cities, according to the massive 2015 National Survey on Drug Use and Health. Depression, thoughts of suicide, and mental illness are more common. CDC statistics show that the overdose fatality rate has tripled since 2000 in small cities and rural areas, surpassing the rate in big cities. Income is lower, according to Census data, as is labor force participation.

Social scientists have already begun to debate which of these factors mattered in the 2016 election. Overdose fatality rates appear to be correlated with county-levels gains in Republican votes, as first reported by sociologist Shannon Monnat. So do indicators of poor health, according to data assembled by The Economist.

Some of the Rust Belt counties that flipped from Democrat to Republican in this election are among the hardest hit by addiction, according to historian Kathleen Frydl.

Much of this trend may also be explained by lower levels of education, as statistician Nate Silver has noted. Outmigration of healthy younger adults might be driving disparities as well.

Also, it is not clear that the election results would have been different if meth counties in swing states had voted for Trump at the rate of comparable non-meth counties, in part because meth labs are concentrated in counties that account for a small portion of the states’ total population.

Still, a partisan meth vote is new. Voters in counties averaging one or more annual drug lab busts in 2004-2007 favored Barack Obama over John McCain by a small margin. In 2012, Obama lost to Mitt Romney by less than a tenth of one percent in counties averaging one or more annual busts in the preceding four years.

The number of lab busts has actually shrunk in recent years. As it has receded from metropolitan areas, meth country looks less and less like the rest of the country. For Clinton supporters who are working on compassion for Trump voters, think of the desperation that might lead people to gamble on a presidential candidate seemingly at odds with small-town values such as honesty, humility, hospitality, and generosity.

If Obamacare is repealed, this gamble may be rewarded with reduced access to substance abuse treatment in parts of the country that need it the most.

Projects:

  • Arab Spring
  • Democracy Denied
  • Forecasting
  • International Education
  • Iran
  • Islamic Parties
  • Islamic Terrorism
  • Liberal Islam
  • Middle East at Carolina
  • Middle East Sociology
  • Modernist Islam
  • The Missing Martyrs
  • World Peace

About Me:

  • Home Page
  • Bio/Contact
  • Curriculum Vitae
  • Teaching/Advising