Charles Kurzman

Skip Navigation
  • 2013
  • 2014
  • 2015
  • 2016
  • 2017
  • 2018
  • 2019
  • A Century of Acceleration
  • Acknowledging State Terrorism
  • Americans’ unfavorable attitudes toward Muslims since 9/11, by party affiliation
  • Arab Spring
    • Winter Without Spring
  • Big Data and Mega Corpora in Middle East Studies
  • CHHS-2019-02-19
  • Confidentiality of Human Research Subjects, 1927
  • Covid Disparities in the United States
  • Crossword Cosmopolitanism
  • Death Tolls of the Iran-Iraq War
  • Forecasting
    • When Forecasts Fail
  • From Brain Drain to Brain Flush
  • International Education
    • Crippling International Education
    • How Global Is K-12 Education in America?
    • Sources and Data
  • Introducing Powerblindness
  • Making the United States Plural Again
  • Middle East Studies at Carolina
  • Nativism, Then and Now
  • Online Catalogs and the Invisible Heritage of Arab Libraries
  • Panopti-Claus
  • President Oligarch
  • Prosecuting Mass Destruction
  • Racial Inequality in the United States
  • Rightwing Postmodernists
  • Syria’s Four Revolutions
  • Syria’s Human Development Crisis
  • Teaching Middle East Crises
  • Ten Unfortunate Place-Names
  • Thank You, Civil Society
  • The Destruction of Syria
  • The Disparaging Implications of Strategic Location
  • The False Premise of Travel Ban 3.0
  • The Man Who Broke the World
  • The Meth Vote
  • When Republicans Needed Muslim Allies
  • Who Polices the Police?
  • Women’s Assessments of Gender Equality
  • #4 (no title)
  • Bio/Contact
  • Democracy Denied
  • Iran
    • Hard-Liners Agree: Good Riddance to Iran Nuclear Deal!
    • The Khomeini Wanna-Be
  • Curriculum Vitae
  • Islamic Parties
  • Islamic Terrorism
    • Chasing the Ghosts of Violent Extremism in the Middle East
    • Data Sources and Suggested Readings
    • Gremlins of Terror
    • Prism’s Paltry Yield
    • The Heresy of the Hijackers
    • The Rights of Roamers
  • Liberal Islam
    • Liberal Islam Web Links
  • Modernist Islam
  • Teaching/Advising
    • Teaching the Middle East in 10 Quiz Questions
    • Social Theory
  • Muslim-American Terrorism
    • Annual Report
    • Press Release, March 9, 2011
  • The Missing Martyrs
    • Q & A on The Missing Martyrs
  • World Peace
    • Will $500 Billion Make America Feel Secure?
Home » Thank You, Civil Society

Thank You, Civil Society

Tent erected at UNC Hospital in preparation for COVID-19 patients. Brian Keyes, The Daily Tar Heel, March 19, 2020.

Charles Kurzman, “Thank You, Civil Society,” March 23, 2020.

As COVID-19 spread around the world, countless organizations have had to make wrenching decisions. How should they prepare for the inevitable arrival of the virus? How should they balance health concerns and their organizational mission? How could they reconfigure themselves to maintain some aspects of their operations?

Members of these organizations spent long days and nights thinking through options, developing plans, keeping stakeholders informed, then starting over the next day based on updated information. In this moment of vulnerability and anxiety, it is heartwarming to see civil society roar into action.

In a decentralized system such as the United States’ that leans heavily on nongovernmental and local institutions, the mobilization of civil society – however chaotic-seeming and inconsistent – is the result of thousands of groups taking their responsibilities seriously.

In my neighborhood, for example, highly responsible people created a buddy system for households who may need help getting groceries and prescriptions. Our public schools, along with volunteers and religious groups, established a delivery network for families who rely on school lunches.

At the university where I work, a crisis group convened to figure out how to protect tens of thousands of students, staff, and community members, while continuing our teaching, research, and service to the extent that we can perform these roles safely. The university consulted with our campus experts on infectious disease – it helps to have some of the world’s foremost experts on staff – and worked with our technology offices to prepare for online operations on a far greater scale than we have ever attempted.

When the virus appeared in our state, the university extended spring break to give instructors an extra week to take their courses online. When the virus appeared in our county, the university reduced in-person operations to essentials. By the time the virus appeared on campus, the university hospitals had procedures in place to provide state-of-the-art treatment while minimizing the risk of further infection.

Some organizations responded to the crisis more quickly; some have moved more gradually. I have no way to evaluate the wisdom of each step along the way, but I know how much effort and care went into wrestling with these decisions every day, and I want to say how much I appreciate it.

In more centralized countries, a single national leader makes decisions and local institutions implement them. That has never been the case in the United States, even in national emergencies. For all its massive power, the federal government has always relied on non-governmental partners, as well as state and local governments. The United States does not have a national blood bank, for example – the main institutions for donating and distributing blood are independent nonprofits. Health insurance is handled primarily by private organizations, many of them for-profit businesses; so are ambulances and emergency rooms and much of the health-care and medical-supply system.

Even a responsible White House would have had difficulty coordinating all of these organizations.

The American system is designed to be self-coordinating, with all the messiness that that entails. Sometimes the messiness is totally worth it – autonomy and variety and experimentation can be empowering and effective. Sometimes the messiness seems like a bad deal – perhaps food security, for example, should be a national guarantee, instead of relying on charity to provide basic needs. When this moment of crisis passes, we may want to re-think the balance between do-it-yourself social welfare and nationally guaranteed subsistence.

In the meantime — thank you, civil society. You are amazing.

Projects:

  • Arab Spring
  • Democracy Denied
  • Forecasting
  • International Education
  • Iran
  • Islamic Parties
  • Islamic Terrorism
  • Liberal Islam
  • Middle East at Carolina
  • Middle East Sociology
  • Modernist Islam
  • The Missing Martyrs
  • World Peace

About Me:

  • Home Page
  • Bio/Contact
  • Curriculum Vitae
  • Teaching/Advising